As Ocean Mommy has now outed me as an American Idol fan, on her blog, I figured we might make this a little fun and pick the top 12 before the next round begins. We'll have a little pick it contest for bragging rights in The Parsonage. I'll list mine in elimination order going from first to go to the final's winner.
12. Kristy Lee Cook - Unimpressed overall with her singing. She tried for the country thing last week & I thought she bombed. She should not be in the top 12.
11. Ramiele Muladay - Another that I am unimpressed with overall. She's had her moments but has slipped as of late.
10. David Hernandez - I think David H. is the first guy to go. He was on the bubble for me last week, but better than the 2 that got cut. Maybe he should have stuck to his other profession.
9. Syesha Mercado - Better than the first 2 girls to go, but is the Simon term "forgettable." She could possibly make it further, but no way she makes it to the final four. She is gonna have to step up her game.
8. Chikezie - This is unfortunate, because I actually like him. But I don't think he has it in him to go much farther than this & I think the musical styles he can sing may be limited. That is what got Mandisa a couple of seasons ago.
7. David Cook - David is pretty good at what he does when he sticks with what he does well. He is not one of my favorites, but his musical ability will do well for him outside of Idol.
6. Amanda Overmyer - Our rockin', bike ridin' nurse. I mentally can't get past the image of her looking like something out of "Cats." But she has consistently gotten better each week, and seems to be finding her niche.
5. Jason Castro - Jason is a very interesting young man. I could see him slipping up early with the wrong song & being #9 or 10 in the elimination process, but I think he's young enough & unique enough that America will keep him around for a while.
4. Brooke White - I'll admit that I have not liked Brooke from the beginning. Just something about her & her music. That said, I'm coming around to like her music. The last 2 weeks have been much better. But I think that American will unplug the Carly Simon look-a-like before we get to the finals.
3. Carly Smithson - A very interesting young woman who's music seem to fit the music she has chosen. At this point in the competition, America is picking the one who want it more and who can consistently perform week after week. I think we'll tire of her before the finals.
2. Michael Johns - Our pop Aussie from GA. I think he has what it takes to make it to the finals and to win if my #1 slips. He has what it takes to perform week after week and do all the different styles of music. I like him a lot, I'm just not sure if he has what it takes to beat America's new favorite son.
1. David Archuletta - America's new favorite son. Can he run for President yet?? Musically he is head and shoulders above everyone else. The only question is is age & can he mentally stand up to the coming weeks.
My Dark Horse - Brooke White. If she can prove to America that she is more than the Carly Simon look & sound-a-like, & do more than just what is in her comfort zone, I could see her in the finals with the possibility of winning it all.
So that's it, let me know how crazy I am. Feel free to post your own list & we'll see how close we get.