Tuesday, April 1, 2008

Amercan Idol top 9

Ok I'm going to try to keep up with A.I. tonight and put my thoughts down as they sing.

Dolly Parton tonight?? Should be interesting.

Brooke - very nice job behind the guitar. She continues to improve each week & I have officially been won over. Simon is a dork - she did a good job.

David C - Wow... Just told Ocean Mommy that if I could buy his last few songs that he has done I would. I did not like him to start with, but he has turned into the rocker with soul. The arrangement made the song. Great job. Simon is again... a dork.

Ramiele - Southern gospel is not her strong suit and that is what this sounds like. Absoultely does not fit her. Bad song...Not very good.

Jason - I like this for Jason. The song fits the style he is good at. Very nice song choice & arrangement. Good job

Carly - I've got chills as she sings. Very very nice. She should be proud of tonight. Sing on Carly - sing on!!! The dork conitnues to speak. There is a difference between constructive criticism and just being mean - and he was mean.

David A. - Very nice soulful county ballad. Very good song choice. I just love this kid who just seems genuine to the core. I'll decide on best of the night after I've heard them all - but this will be at the top.

Kristy Lee - She must be a Virginia Tech fan becasue that was "Hokie". I continue to be underwhelmed by her. When will she go home.

Syesha - I completely forgot Dolly wrote this song. Syesha does a very simple version - she's not trying to be Whitney, which is a good thing. I like it a lot - very strong.

Michael - Very nice. He continues to impress. I still think he ends up in the finals.

Best:
Brooke
David Cook

Worst:
Ramiele
Kristy Lee

Please God - help us end our misery & send our unimpressive country girl home.

Until tomorrow night...